Someone to walk all over me

I wasn’t planning to post on this episode right away, but readers need a place to put comments, so I will start with some thoughts. The episode was a good one but wasn’t tremendously surprising to some. Many were of the opinion that Boomer was still working for Cavil and they were right. And we’ve always known that Starbuck was under the influence of the mysterious string-puller who showed her a vision of Leoben and gave her a destiny. Now that we know the Final Five wake-up wasn’t part of their own plan or Cavil’s, it has to have come from the string-puller, who likes All Along the Watchtower (whether Anders wrote it or not.) And Hera’s been involved in the visions of the Opera House, which are also clearly the work of the string-puller/One-true-god.

Still, the depth of the betrayal was good and shocking. The kidnapping in a box. The sex. The building of a complete fantasy world, complete with kid, to seduce Tyrol. When she leaves him, she tells him she truly felt all that.

Perhaps she did. This is the Boomer who, along with Caprica Six, seemingly saved the human race by convincing the Cylons not to kill them on New Caprica. She betrayed Adama and shot him, but due to programming. Now she’s ready to betray those she loved, as she betrayed her own model line.

Is it possible that she has been programmed by Cavil? This would disappoint me, I want my characters to be acting of their own will, make their own choices for their own reasons, but it is not out of the question here. The other, nice alternative is that she and Tyrol had a plan ready to betray Cavil (“I’m not sure I can do this on my own”) though it is clear that Tyrol didn’t realize a Hera kidnapping was part of what was going on. Where did he think he was sending her? To wander the stars in a Raptor until she runs out of air? Why did she ask him to come with her?

And I liked the stronger use of piano music. Though I kept expecting them to break out into “Someone to watch over me” at some point, not the All Along the Watchtower bass line.

A few other notes:

A Stream of Stars

Michael Hall, who has been diligent in finding Earth star patterns in recent episodes, has now found them in too many places, including the Ionian Nebula from the start of season 4 and after jumps from there. In spite of what seemed like a strong message with:

  • The most well known constellations being presented blatantly over the Cylon battle location and other locations
  • The use of random constellations over the 13th colony

May be just poor work on the part of the graphics dept. Clearly they have two modules for doing their backgrounds in post, one for the real solar system stars, another for random stars. They never used the real system stars until season 4, which seemed like a signal, but they’ve used them willy-nilly. While they would not expect most fans to have fancy star pattern matching software, the use of Orion and the Big Dipper did not require this to match.

So we have to seriously reduce the confidence we can make in predictions based on those star patterns.

Anders’ last words

Anders’ memories caused him to shout out “stay with the fleet. It’s coming. The miracle.” to the others. Doesn’t Ellen have these memories? It sure seems she would be asked about them, but we still learn no more.

That Seven

While we are told to not expect much more of Daniel in this show (though those saying he is Starbuck’s dad got a boost) we should pay attention to the exact wording of what they said about him. When Ellen talks of Daniel, Cavil says, “that seven was…” This suggests there were, at that time, multiple sevens. And Anders, though mumbling words, calls him “the Daniel.” So Daniel might not have been the original #7, though Cavil does seem to have shut down the further duplication of that line.

Poor Galactica

It will be sad when she breaks up. Just a few more jumps. We at least learn that jumping inside a ship is bad news. And it was so nice to see the cliche space opera scene of the ship racing for the closing doors of the launch bay — and this time actually hit the wall. Of course the bad guys always do hit the wall in that scene after the good guys sneak through, and Boomer is now fully bad guy. Curious that the Tylium ship was able to jump away while vipers were trying to land on it to board it, and they were not hurt.

Don't lend things to your brother

Again, it's been years, I don't recall the film as well as i wish I did. I lost my dvd copy years ago sadly. As best I can recall, though, didn't it just turn out that she left him because she couldn't deal with his insanity, and he invented the whole murder mystery himself to give his life meaning? How is this a paradox? I'm confused. I need to find that DVD... I think I lent it to my brother. Grr.

This bridge has developed a

This bridge has developed a troll. I think it is time to disable the open commentary.

Irony

Funny, I nearly said the same thing yesterday. I can't speak for others but I've been just about the biggest ass-kisser of Brad that's going and it's been the sensible people who've been starting riots. But if you want to scapegoat someone go right ahead. I know when someone cashes my cheques and you'll have to live with that. You just ain't gonna get another one if you pull that trigger.

Note on comment thread rules

The comment threads are here to discuss the show and related issues. Discussion of the people in the threads is uninteresting to me and everybody else.

Please do not write things about other posters, notably insults or criticisms of them. You can criticise ideas but not people. Don’t make comments on their motives, education or intelligence.

If somebody makes a comment about you, do not reply. Chances are that your reply will be deleted anyway when the parent comment is deleted.

You can insult me, the host, if you need to, but I don’t tend to respond to comments that imagine my own state of mind instead of addressing what I wrote.

Threads of back and forth discussion about people rather than BSG will get deleted if they get bad. If you find yourself writing somebody else’s name in a post, or even writing in the second person, as in using the word “you” rather than “that concept” then pull back and don’t post.

This goes doubly so for people posting as Anonymous. I let such people post, but I won’t let them make the threads become boring with flamewars. There are lots of online places you can do that.

Creating an account on the site is not required, but if you do, you get the ability to edit your posts after the fact, save settings and so on. I may take some time to approve it however, I had to turn accounts into requiring approval after spammers created hundreds of accounts.

Another Episode of Filler!

Just finished watching today's BSG, I am sorry to say this whole season could have been done in 4 hours. I struggled to stay awake at times. Even the most ardent fan of this show has to admit that this is being teased out with 10 min. of worthwhile material and 30 minutes of material that should have ended up on the editing room floor.

I wished the hype even came close to the reality. I am missing Gaeta and Zarek right now.

Filler Fatique? Maybe.

I'll admit to feeling like it's filler, but in reality, it's in our heads. Had there been a season 5, we'd be enjoying it more, but the fact is, we're all so eager to get answers that we're looking past what's going on, not seeing the forest for the tress as it were. It's not your fault, of course, as i'm doing the same thing-- it's a natural impulse in this situation. It's like getting to the last chapter of a long murder mystery where the murderer isn't revealed until the very last sentence: the last chapter is filled with lots of good character moments, nice drama, but you so badly just want to skip ahead to the last page and see who did it.

The show has always been more about the human drama than the mysteries and plot twists, but the fact is, they billed this season with the tagline 'You Will Know The Truth'.

So on the one hand I don't blame them, they're writing the show they want to write, but on the other hand, they should have anticipated us feeling this way (and with that tagline, they clearly did) and gone to greater lengths to pace out the revelations a little better.

A new posting is opened

For discussion of Islanded in a sea of stars.

I don't believe starbuck is

I don't believe starbuck is a cylon/human hybrid, but full blooded cylon. I believe she is in fact zoe, the very first caprican made sentient cylon, and also daniel graystone's daughter. I also believe daniel greystone is the daniel they mention as being the cylon that cavil killed.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

His name is Brad Templeton. You figure it out.
Please make up a name if you do not wish to give your real one.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Personal home pages only. Posts with biz home pages get deleted and search engines ignore all links
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options