Thanks for a well thought out commentary on the issue -- that's been very lacking. I never thought about how proponents of "keeping the internet free and accessible to all" will likely wind up causing usage-based fees, which will make the 'net more restrictive. I may just have to change my stance on net neutrality.

In any case, why not just allow ISPs to do whatever, just require them to disclose their bandwidth rules free of charge to anyone who requests it?