You must realize that Moore will, as he did with Starbuck’s “Death” both equivocate and outright lie on central issues like this one. However, he doesn’t have to lie. Read his words carefully. He does not say it, he says “he didn’t want [EW] to ferret that out.” He may have not wanted them to ferret that out because it’s false, for example.

2.) No, just that sentence. He’s talking about who he would make be these 4 Cylons.

3) Look at my blog post about what Baltar said to 3, about which “you were right” could apply.

5) Tons of threads in every online forum on battlestar. But truth is, he just assigned the numbers at random, before he had the final 5 plan I suspect.

So while Dualla is a candidate if you buy it’s a minor character, nothing in your list except her name applies to her, and could not apply to other minor characters like Gaeta, Zarek etc.

But the big reason I don’t give much weight to them. It would be boring. Lah-de-dah. Now if we see a lot more character development for Dee or Gaeta or somebody else, that will change my view. But if it does turn out to be her, the reaction will be, “oh. Ok, I guess it could be her.” Not. “Holy Shit!”

I predict this revelation, like Tigh/Tyrol/Anders/Foster will generate a “Holy Shit!” Anything less would not live up to the standards of the show. Actually, this is the one strike against Baltar — too many clues.