With interesting elements. We know Baltar is "the chosen one" for something, and was right about what he told D'Anna.

However, there is a real Cylon God out there, who was in communication with that First Hybrid. That first Hybrid knows the story, so who is he in your version? Who are the other Hybrids who it appears know Baltar is special too? Who rescued Starbuck and took her to Earth? Who arranged the Galactica's escape from the war, putting the final 5 aboard her?

There has to be somebody/something out there who is aware of the story and who is making events happen.