External laptop batteries, especially on planes

Recently I purchased an external battery for my Thinkpad. The internal batteries were getting weaker, and I also needed something for the 14 hour overseas flights. I picked up a generic one on eBay, a 17 volt battery with about 110 watt-hours, for about $120. It's very small, and only about 1.5 lbs. Very impressive for the money. (When these things first came out they had half the capacity and cost more like $300.)

There are downsides to an external: The laptop doesn't know how much charge is in the battery and doesn't charge it. You need an external charger. My battery came with its own very tiny charger which is quite slow (it takes almost a day to recharge from a full discharge.) The battery has its own basic guage built in, however. An external is not as efficient as an internal (you convert the 17v to the laptop's internal voltage and you also do wasteful charging of the laptop's internal if it is not full, though you can remove the internal at the risk of a sudden cutoff should you get to the end of the external's life.)

However, the plus is around 9 to 10 hours of life in a small, cheap package, plus the life of your laptop's internal battery. About all you need for any flight or long day's work.

It's so nice that in fact I think it's a meaningful alternative to the power jacks found on some airlines, usually only in business class. I bought an airline adapter a few years ago for a similar price to this battery, and even when I have flown in business class, half the time the power jack has not been working properly. Some airlines have power in coach but it's rare. And it costs a lot of money for the airlines to fit these 80 watt jacks in lots of seat, especially with all the safety regs on airlines.

I think it might make more sense for airlines to just offer these sorts of batteries, either free or for a cheap rental fee. Cheaper for them and for passengers than the power jacks. (Admittedly the airline adapter I bought has seen much more use as a car and RV adapter.) Of course they do need to offer a few different voltages (most laptops can take a range) but passengers could reserve a battery with their flight reservation to be sure they get the right one.

It would be even cheaper for airlines to offer sealed lead-acid batteries. You can buy (not rent) an SLA with over 200 watt-hours (more than you need for any flight) for under $20! The downside is they are very heavy (17lbs) but if you only have to carry it onto the plane from the gate this may not be a giant barrier.

Of course, what would be great would be a standard power plug on laptops for external batteries, where the laptop could use the power directly, and measure and charge the external. Right now the battery is the first part to fail in a laptop, and as such you want to replace batteries at different times from laptops. This new external should last me into my next laptop if it is a similar voltage.

lead batteries are a bad idea

Airlines care a lot more about weight than you do. If they rented out batteries I expect they'd go for lithium or NiMH because of that. It'd be interesting to see how the economics actually worked out.

There's also the question of giving someone 5kg of dense, caustic material with easily accessible energy (even an SLA will give you a decent spark or red hot wire). The anti-tourist people would probably veto it just on those grounds (but still let you take your laptop battery).

Yeah, I thought about these

Yeah, I thought about these things but didn't want to go into them. My Li-ion battery has an energy density 1/6th of TNT (4 MJ/kg) (but then a candy bar has even more, but you can't release it quickly.) The SLA battery is of course much less (it weighs 4 times as much). The weight issue depends on how much they save on the battery.

The caustic isn't a problem with SLAs. They will let SLAs on board, but not spillable ones. They are often found in power chairs, medical equipment etc.

sla batterys

only come in increments of 1.5 volts how ever the voulume to engey racial of sla is prety high and u can release it pretty quick take7.2 ah 12 volt and u can pull a 30 amp short a 200 ah 12 vilt sla will start a car and that is what u will find in a wheelchair

so i dont think souces of large amounts of power are a concern

or maybe a cripple could never be a terrorist

how ever it is possable to make a battery out of a bottle of diet rite and with out saying how it could be used as a bomb just by containing an internal short circuit and containing the resulting sodium build up from the high salt content but u could still take a bottle of diet rite on board just not a bottle of deit rite configured as a bomb

the amount of electrical power from a diet rite battery would be less than a aa battery

air port security is a tricky bussness ask why you cant have toe nail clippers but can have a pistol in your checked loggage

External laptop batteries, especially on planes

Brad talked about "a generic one on eBay, a 17 volt battery with about 110 watt-hours, for about $120. It's very small, and only about 1.5 lbs."
I would like to know the manufacturer, brand and model of this battery.
I do not mind the slow charging rate. The important thing is the light
weight of 1.5 lbs which interests me very much. I would appreciate it very
much if you would answer me to my E-mail address. Thank you

Alas

It’s one of those chinese items with no brand name on it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

His name is Brad Templeton. You figure it out.
Please make up a name if you do not wish to give your real one.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Personal home pages only. Posts with biz home pages get deleted and search engines ignore all links
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options