Internet TV, I'm waiting for you
I'm an earlier adopter with my mythTV box and fast connection. But I'm really keen to see the move to getting TV shows over IP. Cable's bulk pricing just isn't doing it for me any more.
I get many shows now via broadcast digital TV, and while I think this is a giant waste of spectrum, while it's there I will certainly use it. So I've started examining just how much I get from my cable. Of course your tastes will vary, but I find I'm starting to care about only 3 or 4 channels. And since I'm paying $45/month plus tax for expanded basic cable from Comcast, that's a great deal of money per channel. Those channels would be wise to start becoming available over the net, because we early adopters will pay nice prices compared to what the cable companies are paying.
The key is that with the MythTV or other DVR, you stop channel surfing. You pick the programs you like, and it records all of them and you don't watch random shows. (Except for Tivo-style "suggestions.")
Even though you limit your TV to just a subset of shows, you quickly are surprised to change the "500 channels and nothing on" problem into "just a few shows and always something good ready to watch." Surfing and deliberate watching are just that different.
So the shows on cable I'm watching are the Daily Show (and somtimes a few other Comedy Central programs), some SF shows on the Sci-Fi Channel, and Mythbusters on the Discovery Channel. Then, during certain events, I will go to the 24 hour news channels, the only things I ever find myself watching live. (Read on...) <!..break..> Now news, as it turns out, is the one thing that makes sense to be broadcast. It's the only thing (along with its cousin, sports) we all want to watch the moment it's produced. For the rest the delayed gratification of TV over IP, or even DVD rental through the mail, is just fine.
And indeed, the SF shows and Mythbusters will all appear on DVD 1-2 years after airing. The Daily Show is making itself available via the non-linux streaming media formats in reduced resolution, so it's not quite ready for me, and it, as a form of news, needs to get to me right away. (The Daily show is on over the air TV in Canada.)
The TV shows on DVD are much better quality than analog broadcast, and of course inherently commercial free. They're not HD yet, though. And the pointless delay, even though they get more money from people who buy or even rent DVDs than they do from advertisers at broadcast time. There is a 24 hour news channel made by ABC available over the air here.
The point is, if I could get my Daily Show in good quality and a format I can play on my system, I think I would be ready to drop my cable. The rest of my non-network watching would be on DVDs and the other brave shows willing to deliver to me this way, at a fair price -- $1/hour for two adults, commercial free, if I buy in bulk. That would leave me without CNN, though the web is mostly substituting for that now, breaking news even faster than it does.
Of course there are people who watch shows from large numbers of channels who love the big bundling. They will hate this idea. But I expect most DVR users are seeing the number of non-network channels they watch drop, and the economics are changing.
(There are some intermediate alternatives. Dish Network has a $27/month package with the channels I want. Sadly, satellite systems don't interface nearly as well with digital video recorders as analog cable does. Starchoice has a $20 CDN package but it has few of the classic cable channels, though it does provide The Daily Show, the Colbert Report, a couple of 24 hour news and lots of Canadian shows. About $18 USD after taxes.)